From Kibble to Raw: The Best Types of Dog Food Explained by a Vet

Types of Dog Food: A Veterinarian's Guide to Choosing the Best Diet for Your Pet

As a responsible pet owner, choosing the right type of food for your dog is one of the most important decisions you can make. A well-balanced diet is essential for maintaining a dog's overall health, energy levels, and longevity. With so many different types of dog food available, it can be overwhelming to determine which one is best for your furry friend. This guide will break down the various types of dog food, their benefits and drawbacks, and how to select the most suitable diet based on your dog's needs.

dry food vs dry food for dogs

1- Dry Dog Food - Kibble Dog Food, what is?

Dry dog food, commonly known as kibble, is one of the most popular and widely available options for feeding dogs.

It is made by mixing various ingredients, including meats, grains, vitamins, and minerals, into a dough that is then cooked and processed into small, bite-sized pieces.

One of the main benefits of a dry dog food diet is that it is convenient. And, because it can be stored and transported easily, buying dry dog food in bulk could work out to be more economical.

Dry dog food is generally less messy than wet and can be left out for a while without the worry of it becoming contaminated with bacteria. This is beneficial if you have small children or live with someone whose immune system is compromised.

Soaking dry kibble will soften the food which will be of benefit to a puppy that is weaning or an older dog that has tooth problems. Also, if you use warm water to soak the dry food it will bring out the meaty smell which dogs are attracted to. Kibble can also be used as a training treat.

Due to the size of dry dog food, it is easy to hide in toys and this can provide stimulation and entertainment for your pet, especially if they are left at home when you are at work or out for a short while. Another benefit of dry dog food is that it is crunchy and because of its shape, when dogs chew, the sharp edges can act as an oral aid to help reduce the build-up of plaque and tartar, potentially resulting in better breath and healthier gums.

Drawbacks of Kibble:

Lower Moisture Content: Can contribute to dehydration if dogs do not drink enough water.

Quality Variations: Not all kibble is made with high-quality ingredients; some contain artificial additives and fillers.

Processing: High-heat processing can reduce the nutritional value of some ingredients.

2- Wet Dog Food or Canned Dog Food

What is Wet Food?

Wet dog food, or canned food, is made with a higher moisture content, often containing real chunks of meat, vegetables, and grains. It is cooked at high temperatures to ensure safety and longevity.

Benefits:

Adds hydration

There are some dogs that are reluctant to drink enough water each day to stay well hydrated. I'm not saying that they need just this source of water. One of the key benefits of feeding your dog wet food is added hydration, as wet food has a much higher moisture content than dry food.

Tempts picky eaters

Wet dog food is an excellent choice for fussy eaters that need to be tempted at mealtimes. Dogs have a great sense of smell and the rich. Due to its soft texture, wet pet food may also be beneficial for both younger and older pets. It’s easier to chew and swallow for pets with fewer teeth, or those with sensitive gums. In addition, older animals with a deteriorating sense of smell and taste may benefit from wet food in their diet as it may have a richer scent and flavor.

Weight Management

Wet food has a higher moisture content compared to dry food. The increased water volume in the food means that it can help pets to feel fuller, helping to promote satiety. This is important for weight management and for those dogs that can be greedy and show begging behaviors. Due to the water content, calories are diluted in the food, so wet food will have a lower caloric density when compared to dry food. It’s important to watch portion sizes carefully with wet food since it’s tastier, but with the right management, it can be a great option for a weight management program.

Wet food is a great mixer

A wet food diet can be a good choice for your dog if you’re noticing your pet is turning up their nose to dry meals. If you are considering a change to your dog’s diet or transitioning to wet food from dry, remember it’s best to introduce them to new foods gradually. This helps avoid sudden digestive upsets that have the potential to disrupt their health. It will also help introduce them slowly to new textures and smells. Some owners find a combination diet works best for their dog and will mix wet food with dry kibble to give their dog some variety at mealtime.

Drawbacks of Wet Food:

More Expensive: Costs more per serving than kibble.

Shorter Shelf Life: Once opened, it needs to be refrigerated and consumed within a few days.

Can Contribute to Dental Issues: If not supplemented with dental treats or brushing, wet food can contribute to plaque buildup.

3- Raw Food Diet (BARF & Prey Model)

What is a Raw Diet?

A raw food diet consists of uncooked meats, bones, organ meats, fruits, and vegetables. The most common raw feeding approaches include the BARF (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food) diet and the Prey Model diet.

BARF rations are oriented towards adapting the predator-prey system for domestic dogs and cats, giving them food consisting essentially of raw meat, with a high proportion of “meaty bones” and organs

The most important motive for an owner in choosing a BARF diet for their pet is the desire for a “more natural, healthier food”. Other reasons include a chronic illness (such as skin disease, gastrointestinal disorders and allergies) which the owner hopes will improve on the new diet, and various claims that commercial ready-to-serve foods contain only “waste materials and chemical ingredients” and are responsible for various diseases. These stories make many pet owners feel insecure and cause them to search for “healthier” alternatives.

The information sources for BARF are primarily internet sites and books. Unfortunately, these sources are normally written by lay people and contain misleading or even inaccurate information, although they may be presented in a very scientific style. BARF is frequently propagated in a very emotional manner and portrayed as a cure-all for diseases, problems and behavioral abnormalities. This can result in some owners, who would not normally consider feeding their pet raw food, being convinced that they will injure their pet by feeding them commercial diets.

Benefits of a Raw Diet:

High in Natural Nutrients: Raw feeding maintains natural vitamins, enzymes, and amino acids.

Better Digestion: Many dogs experience improved digestion and fewer allergies.

Healthier Coat and Skin: Natural oils and fats contribute to a shinier coat.

Drawbacks of a Raw Diet:

Risk of Bacterial Contamination: Handling raw meat requires careful hygiene to avoid foodborne illnesses.

Nutritional Imbalance: Without proper planning, raw diets can lack essential nutrients.

Cost and Storage Issues: Requires freezer space and can be expensive.

4- Home-Cooked Dog Food

What is Home-Cooked Food?

Home-cooked meals for dogs involve preparing fresh, cooked ingredients such as lean meats, vegetables, grains, and healthy fats.

Benefits of Home-Cooked Food:

Full Control Over Ingredients: Allows customization for dietary needs and allergies.

Highly Digestible: Freshly cooked meals are easy on a dog’s stomach.

No Artificial Additives: Free from preservatives, fillers, and artificial ingredients.

Drawbacks of Home-Cooked Food:

Time-Consuming: Requires planning, preparation, and cooking time.

Nutritional Imbalance Risk: Without veterinary guidance, meals may lack essential nutrients.

Short Shelf Life: Needs refrigeration and has a shorter shelf life compared to kibble.

5. Veterinary Prescription Diets

What are Prescription Diets?

Veterinary prescription diets are specially formulated foods designed to manage specific health conditions such as kidney disease, obesity, or food allergies. These diets are available through veterinarians and require a prescription.

Benefits of Prescription Diets:

Tailored for Health Issues: Helps manage chronic conditions effectively.

Scientifically Formulated: Created with precise nutrient balance for specific health needs.

How to Choose the Best Dog Food for Your Pet

Choosing the best type of dog food depends on various factors, including your dog’s age, breed, activity level, and health conditions. Learn more about it here

Here are some key considerations:

Assess Your Dog’s Needs: Consider factors such as age (puppy, adult, senior), size, activity level, and specific health concerns.

Check Ingredient Quality: Look for high-quality protein sources, healthy fats, and essential vitamins and minerals.

Consider Your Lifestyle: If convenience is a priority, kibble or freeze-dried food may be ideal. If you have the time and resources, home-cooked or raw food may be suitable.

Consult Your Veterinarian: Always discuss dietary changes with your vet, especially if your dog has special dietary requirements.

Monitor Your Dog’s Health: Pay attention to energy levels, coat condition, stool consistency, and overall health to ensure their diet is meeting their needs.

Conclusion

With so many options available, selecting the right type of dog food can feel overwhelming. Whether you choose kibble, wet food, raw, freeze-dried, home-cooked, or a veterinary-prescribed diet, the key is ensuring it meets your dog's nutritional needs. Consulting with a veterinarian and carefully considering your pet’s individual requirements will help you make the best decision for their long-term health and well-being.

If you want to learn more about dog feeding mistakes here you can find more:  How an Imbalanced Diet Affects Bone & Joint Health

You may also like:

- A Comprehensive Guide to High-Protein Treats